Gaurika Kumar
Homeland is a TV show about Carrie Mathison
(played by Claire Danes) who has Bipolar Disorder and has been critically
acclaimed for being one of the best representations of mental illnesses on
television in recent years The show revolves around her life and the challenges
she faces while tackling international crises. It discusses themes of counterterrorism
and espionage, and takes place in different locations including America,
Pakistan, and Germany. Despite the unreliability and unpredictability that
accompanies bipolarity, Carrie is at the top of her profession as a
high-ranking agent at the CIA. It is an important show to discuss and dissect because
the disorder isn’t used as a tool to progress the storyline, or as the main
plot, but is rather carefully curated as a part of Carrie’s character.
Bipolar Disorder is a mood disorder in
which a person experiences episodes of both depression and mania. Genetic and
biological factors have been known to play a part in the existence of
bipolarity. Neurochemical imbalances, abnormalities of the
hypothalamic-pituitary-adrenal axis, and disturbances in biological rhythms all
play important roles in bipolar disorders[i]. Although this genetic predisposition
does make a person vulnerable to this disorder, environmental stressors also
contribute to, and often provoke, these emotional excesses. Carrie Mathison,
being a daughter of a man with bipolar disorder, and a CIA agent, always finds
herself in high-powered, high-stress situations. This makes her case especially
interesting because due to the constant presence of stressors in her life it is
difficult to gauge what is her inherent personality, and what behaviours occur
because of her disorder. Is Carrie a good spy because of her genius and acumen
for the profession, or does her bipolarity contribute to it?
In bipolar disorder, the symptoms of mania and
depression manifest in different ways. In manic phases, people have euphoria or
heightened irritability, rapid thoughts, a surplus of ideas, inflated
self-esteem, unusual energy and impulsiveness[ii]. This can make people
dysfunctional, but in some cases can increase their productivity. As shown in
the show, Carrie has had several breakthroughs in her work during this manic
phase which becomes evident in season one of Homeland, when she willingly goes
off her meds to track a terrorist, and successfully manages to do so. Another trait
shown in Carrie is her strong sense of self-belief, and intuition. It almost
borders a self-centred nature where anyone who goes against her, or opposes her
is perceived as an enemy. It is difficult to determine whether this confidence
and narcissism arises because of her self-awareness of her intelligence and
genius as an espionage spy, or is caused by her bipolarity. Furthermore, examples
of impulsive and reckless behaviours in patients of bipolar disorder can be
seen through activities like excessive spending, substance abuse, promiscuous sex,
inter alia. Throughout the show, Carrie also engages in sexual activities with
her colleagues and suspects. For example, in season one, she seduces Nicholas
Brody, a prisoner of war who has been suspected of being turned into a
terrorist, and in season four, Ayan, a Pakistani medical student related to a
family of terrorist who were murdered in an air strike launched by Carrie and
her team. It is not known whether these advances made by Carrie were well
thought-out tactics to get close to the suspects, or promiscuous behaviours
caused by her bipolarity.
While her mania is depicted well, Carrie’s depressive phase is also
brilliantly recorded by the show. When she is depressed, she indulges in binge
drinking, sleeps for days, and isolates herself from her family and friends. In
one instance when confronted by Brody to stay away from him and his family,
Carrie seemingly break down and is taken to the hospital for treatment. In the
hospital she goes through severe depression and repeatedly bangs her head
against a bathroom mirror, is anxious, and obsessive. Despite this, even in the
hospital she is dedicated to her work, but when her trustworthy green pen dries
out, we see her spiral and obsessively trying to replace it with a new green
pen. Moreover, her bipolarity also shown to sometimes manifest in mixed
episodes, where she’s ecstatic one minute, and because of a sudden stressor
starts crying and screaming uncontrollably.
Overall the depiction of bipolarity in Homeland is accurate, and has
been appreciated by people who suffer from this disorder themselves making the
character interesting from a dramatic as well as clinical perspective. Dealing
with hostage situations, terrorist plots, murders, pregnancies, and deaths of loved
ones, the show explores different emotions and different ways in which Carrie
deals with them. In an environment where the media is filled with inaccurate
depictions of mental disorders, a representation based on true experiences with
bipolar disorder is refreshing and much needed.
References:
Hannah Jane Parkinson. (2014). Does Homeland Sensationalise Carrie Mathison's Bipolar Disorder?. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/dec/01/homeland-carrie-mathison-bipolar-disorder-claire-danes
Jeffrey Lieberman. (2014). Homeland: A True Portraual of Mental Illness. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/shrink-speak/201411/homeland-true-portrayal-mental-illness
[i] James N. Butcher, Susan Mineka, Jill M. Hooley. (2013). Abnormal Psychology, 15th ed. p. 264
Hannah Jane Parkinson. (2014). Does Homeland Sensationalise Carrie Mathison's Bipolar Disorder?. Retrieved from https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2014/dec/01/homeland-carrie-mathison-bipolar-disorder-claire-danes
Jeffrey Lieberman. (2014). Homeland: A True Portraual of Mental Illness. Retrieved from https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/shrink-speak/201411/homeland-true-portrayal-mental-illness
[i] James N. Butcher, Susan Mineka, Jill M. Hooley. (2013). Abnormal Psychology, 15th ed. p. 264
[ii] American
Psychiatric Association. Treatment of Patients With Bipolar Disorder.
2nd Edition. https://psychiatryonline.org/pb/assets/raw/sitewide/practice_guidelines/guidelines/bipolar.pdf
Comments
Post a Comment