Skip to main content

Misdiagnosing Trump with Narcissistic Personality Disorder: an Example of Confusing Bad Behaviour with Mental Illness

Anandita Lidhoo


“Everyone has a personality,” says Allen Frances,the psychiatrist responsible for the rules for diagnosing personality disorders in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM). “It’s not wrong to have a personality; it’s not mentally ill to have a personality. It’s only a disorder when it causes extreme distress, suffering, and impairment.” He is referring to the recent buzz around Trump’s mental health- the change.org petition with over 70,000 signage's, or a professional analyses on the Atlantic magazine and even Twitter. The discussion revolving around his possible narcissistic personality disorder has become the subject of news and media.

The petition, started by clinical psychologist John Gartner, stirred the most public interest. This is possibly because for the first time, a medical health professional was so vehemently and publicly against a president keeping post while suffering from an array of mental illnesses. Frances, however, believes “what’s going on is bullshit,” arguing that while Trump may satisfy certain criteria in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM) for Narcissistic Personality Disorder (NPD), the story is much bigger than that.

To diagnose a mental disorder, a key criterion that must be satisfied is that the disorder affects the patient’s life in a negative manner. Some of the complications that come with NPD are depression and/or anxiety, trouble at school or work, strained (or lack of many) relationships, drug or alcohol misuse, and thoughts of suicide. Frances explains that people with NPD will, at some point in their lives, experience a crash of some sort, even if they won’t be able to recognize it themselves- familial abandonment, loss of job, and their “bubble of grandiosity will burst.” They will be tormented by feeling like they cannot function or move up in the world.
However, the President is seen to have a supportive, loving family, suffers from no visible signs of depression or anxiety, and claims to be satisfied with his overall economically and politically successful life.

It is understandable that many diagnose him with a disorder from what they can see, but this disobeys the Goldwater rule, which states that psychiatrists are disallowed from making judgements about a public figure’s mental health from afar. Not only is this practice unethical, it is also very dangerous, given how broad the DSM-5 criteria can be, providing opportunity for diagnostic inflation. Since Donald Trump is a controversial political figure, most of the public may not appreciate his policies and behavior, thus making professionals more prone to giving biased opinions. While well-meaning professionals are thus expressing concern over Trump’s position in the government, they are unknowingly stigmatizing many mental illnesses by using them as insults. This causes public to associate mental disorders with bad behavior, which, for most of the mentally ill, is just untrue. Such errors in judgment can hamper the current struggle of normalising and demystifying mental illnesses to encourage healthy dialogue.

It is imperative to draw the line between a strong personality and a mental disorder. Allen Frances, concerned about the practice of clinical psychology, reminds the public, “Trump is not mad, he’s just bad.”

References:
  1. Frances, A. (2017, December 22). An Eminent Psychiatrist Demurs on Trump's Mental State. Retrieved December 18, 2018, from https://www.nytimes.com/2017/02/14/opinion/an-eminent-psychiatrist-demurs-on-trumps-mental-state.html
  2. Frances, A. (2012, December 2). DSM 5 Is Guide Not Bible—Ignore Its Ten Worst Changes. Retrieved December 18, 2018, from https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/dsm5-in-distress/201212/dsm-5-is-guide-not-bible-ignore-its-ten-worst-changes
Wilson, F. P. (2017, September 6). Misdiagnosing Trump: Doc-to-Doc with Allen Frances, MD. Retrieved December 18, 2018, from https://www.medpagetoday.com/psychiatry/generalpsychiatry/67728

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Analysing “Anniyan”: Dissociative Identity Disorder meets Personality Disorders

Pranaya Prakash In the movie “Anniyan” (Shankar, 2005), the protagonist Ramanujam Iyengar, also known as Ambi, is the host of his alters: Remo and Anniyan. While the focus of the movie is only on Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID), also known as Multiple Personality Disorder (MPD), the host, Ambi, and the alter, Anniyan, show symptoms of Obsessive-Compulsive Personality Disorder (OCPD) and Antisocial Personality Disorder (ASPD), respectively. In this blog post, I attempt to critically analyse the portrayal of DID and the possibility of the protagonist having comorbid Personality Disorders. While it is highly unlikely for individuals with DID to have comorbidities with Personality Disorders ( Antisocial Personality Disorder ), especially with OCPD and ASPD (Fink, 1991), it is interesting to think of the possibility and analyse the developmental trajectory of these individuals.  The movie starts with the character development of Ambi, a lawyer who is meticulous and very particular ...
Post a Comment
Read more

Hardin's trauma

“After”, is a 2019 teen romantic drama directed by jenny gage that revolves around the love of  Tessa, an inexperienced teenage girl, with Hardin, a mysterious ‘bad boy’ . Hardin, the main male character, never had a secure relationship with his father. When Hardin was young, his father used to be an alcoholic with a lot of debt. When he was just eight years old, intruders broke into his home looking for his father for money, however, there was only Hardin and his mother. The intruders forced themselves on Hardin’s mother, and Hardin, who was sleeping then, came downstairs to see what was wrong. To Hardin’s shock, his mother was being raped by three men, one by one. Hardin’s mother told him to leave, however, one man forced him to watch everything.  I would assume that Hardin has PTSD as a result of this incident, and in this paper I will try to prove it. Symptoms of PTSD and scenes that prove Hardin had it: The person subsequently re-experiences the event through both intrusi...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Patrick Jane a psychopath?

Under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), Psychopathy was never recognized, until the revised DSM-5 categorized it under Anti-Social Personality Disorder. “He will choose you, disarm you with his words, and control you with his presence” (Hare)  Psychopaths can replicate the behavior which the person they are interacting with thinks they want from them, without feeling a thing, which contributes greatly to their ability to manipulate. Psychopaths charm and lie their way seamlessly to the top, and while they lack empathy, they are well-liked because they know what to say and when to say it. Psychopaths occupy most of the positions of power in our society and corporations and thus often end up being glorified. This glorification of psychopaths is most evident in the portrayal of psychopathy in TV shows. Some of the most notable characters which the screen has ever seen, like Marlo Stanfield from ‘The Wire’, James Moriarty from ‘Sherlock’, Hanni...
Post a Comment
Read more