Skip to main content

Monk and the Portrayal of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder


Image result for monk show

The series Monk is based on Adrian Monk, a consultant for the San Francisco Police Department, who has the uncanny ability to put together the most unnoticed of clues to solve a crime in every episode. Besides his impressive deduction skills, his most noticeable characteristic is his obsessive-compulsive behaviour. Adrian Monk has 312 phobias, ranging from ladybugs to harmonicas. He has a whole host of compulsive behaviours, such as an intense compulsion to touch and count every single parking meter he crosses, to needing a tissue to clean his hands every time he is offered a handshake (the person offering rarely takes this well), to needing everything to be spotlessly clean. Nevertheless, his obsessive nature makes him highly attentive to detail, and allows him to draw relationships in places others overlook. His colleagues who initially dub him the defective detective slowly grow to respect him as he solves case after case for ten seasons.

The main problem with Monk is how Adrian’s OCD is used as a device in the show. His compulsive behaviour is a constantly used as comic trope, and allows for the viewers to laugh at what is in reality a debilitating disorder. Secondly the show rarely shows instances of what it truly means to suffer from OCD, the misery and encumbering nature it can take up when it is at its worst. In an entire eight seasons, Adrian Monk talks about it once when he tells his therapist, “I’m so tired of being me, look at me! I’m helpless, I’m pathetic, I’m not even a man, I’m a broken machine.” Thirdly his OCD consists of cliched symptoms such as his fear of germs, and his need to count and clean objects. In reality, OCD consists of a wide variety of obsessions and compulsions, but the typical portrayal of it in the media leads to the general public not understanding the full scope of how the disorder can affect people. Lastly, Adrian does not seem to gain even the slightest bit of control over his OCD, even through consistent therapy over the years, and even after he changes therapists- a very unlikely scenario in real life. In the end, Adrian has barely gained control over one of his 312 phobias, claustrophobia. Even more strangely, in one particular episode where Adrian tries medication to help his OCD he turns overnight into a changed man. He loses all his OCD symptoms but loses his extraordinary crime-solving abilities as well. The medication appears to have addled his brain, and he loses a part of his personality, enabling the general stigma around taking medication for mental disorders.

Despite all of this, it appears certain organisations have stood by the show. The Anxiety Disorders Association of America released a statement saying they appreciated the efforts put into the show as it helped increase awareness of Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder. (North,2008) The organisation also released a PSA with the actor depicting Adrian Monk, Tony Shalhoub. (OCD PSA)The question is why? Even after all the problems with the show, the character of Adrian Monk is compassionate and lovable. Those around him, even though are often irritated by his many compulsions, care for him and respect him, and see him as much more than his disorder. They see him for the genius he is. His mental illness does not reduce the fact that he is the show’s hero. The show humanises the character. 

This may cause the problem of normalising (or rather, trivialising) the disorder, and people may end up seeing this not as a serious mental health condition but rather a personality trait.
There is a thin line between sensationalisation and trivialisation of something like this, but perhaps it is a line many organisations are willing to tread, when awareness is the goal. Monk may not be a truly accurate representation of OCD, but to people who know absolutely nothing about it, it might act as a starting point.

References:
North, G. (2008, September 04). Orgs praise 'Monk's' depiction of OCD. Retrieved December 2, 2018, from https://variety.com/2008/scene/features/orgs-praise-monk-s-depiction-of-ocd-1117991603/
OCD PSA With "Monk" Star Tony Shalhoub. (n.d.). Retrieved December 2, 2018, from https://adaa.org/about-adaa/press-room/multimedia/ocd-psa-monk-star-tony-shalhoub
Zisk, R.(Director). (2002). Monk [Television series].

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scarlett O' Hara Diagnosed

By Ragini Chatterjee   (Overall Grade Remedial) A case study on Scarlett O' Hara from ‘Gone with The Wind’   Scarlett O' Hara has to be one of the most vivacious character, on print. With her southern Belle ‘ Fiddle de dees ’, bright green eyes and sharp tongue, she is hard to forget. After having seen the movie multiple times from age 13, I was fascinated by her personality. Her antics, at times cruel, bought the story to life. Her obsession with Ashley, her multiple marriages, her cunning mind and relentless spirt were always entertaining from the perspective of the viewer. However, years later as I look back, I can’t help but recognize patterns of behavior that may resonate with some personality disorder. From the beginning of the movie, Scarlett has to be the centre of attention . At the Wilkes Party, in her attempts to drive Ashley jealous, she flirts with every man in sight- Starting with Charles Hamilton, Frank Kennedy, the Tarleton twins, she promis...
Post a Comment
Read more

PTSD and its portrayal in Peaky Blinders

AARYAN SANWAL The award-winning TV series, Peaky Blinders is set in Birmingham, England at the end of the First World War and gives an account of the Peaky Blinders that is headed by the Shelby family. Thomas Shelby was a tunneller in World War I and for his actions, received two medals of honour after the war.   This blog post shall look at the representation of war trauma, its accuracy in depictions and its effects on the lives of the characters. The two main characters that this blog post will be focusing on are Thomas Shelby and Daniel Owen (a.k.a. Danny Whiz-Bang). The two of them were tunnellers in the War and were going through a routine tunnel expedition when the Germans broke through the end of their tunnel and attacked the men in the tunnel and brutally injured Thomas and Daniel. They were able to kill the enemies and leave the tunnels, alive but severely injured. During various instances throughout the show, Thomas Shelby has recurring nightmares of his time i...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Patrick Jane a psychopath?

Under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), Psychopathy was never recognized, until the revised DSM-5 categorized it under Anti-Social Personality Disorder. “He will choose you, disarm you with his words, and control you with his presence” (Hare)  Psychopaths can replicate the behavior which the person they are interacting with thinks they want from them, without feeling a thing, which contributes greatly to their ability to manipulate. Psychopaths charm and lie their way seamlessly to the top, and while they lack empathy, they are well-liked because they know what to say and when to say it. Psychopaths occupy most of the positions of power in our society and corporations and thus often end up being glorified. This glorification of psychopaths is most evident in the portrayal of psychopathy in TV shows. Some of the most notable characters which the screen has ever seen, like Marlo Stanfield from ‘The Wire’, James Moriarty from ‘Sherlock’, Hanni...
Post a Comment
Read more