Skip to main content

Blacking Out as an Escape from the Law

Veeha Verma

Remedial Blog Post for Quiz 11


Excessive alcohol consumption, to the extent where individuals start experiencing blackouts, is certainly not a new phenomenon. Often used as an excuse for several wayward behaviours, “liquid courage” has lain at the heart of several inexplicable situations. While some of these instances are truly harmless in nature, many criminal activities take place under the influence as well. The plead often becomes that the accused were unaware of their actions due to their intoxicated state. So does alcohol act as an amnesia inducing substance, leading their consumers to having no recollection of their own actions? Or, as is increasingly being speculated, is it used as a convenient escape, an excuse for otherwise criminal behaviour?
                A blackout may be understood as, “A phenomenon caused by the intake of any substance or medication in which short term and long term memory creation is impaired, therefore causing a complete inability to recall the past”. There is no way to overstate the role that alcohol plays in cultures around the world, especially college culture. Alcohol consumption is seen as not only a rite of passage for all college students, but also some kind of relief from work and responsibility. However, due to the unrestricted nature in which it is consumed the frequency of blackouts has increased. Unfortunately, this has also led to people refraining from taking responsibility for their actions while intoxicated, claiming they have no memory of the events that took place. Alcohol is known for worsening memory in general, as well as word and object association. This has led to substantiation to the claim that people had no control over their actions while intoxicated. However, where do we draw the line? If blackouts and the actions of individuals experiencing them are not the consumer’s fault, then is the rate of alcohol consumption? How does the law create an allowance for blackout cases and should they in the first place?
                The DSM-IV-TR recognizes organic amnesia and psychogenic amnesia, with three possible diagnostic criteria. The second criterion is that of substance induced amnesia, where blackouts would fall. Recent studies showing the surprising number of blackouts associated with social drinking, statistics showed that 51% of American college students had experienced at least one blackout in their lives. Alcohol abuse is highly related to criminal activities and assaults. At the same time amnesia is implicated in 40-70% homicidal cases. When the two come together in homicidal cases, psychiatrists find themselves heavily compromised on passing any kind of judgement. However, in reality there is no way to test the truth of the claims regarding alcohol-induced amnesia. So how does this affect criminal testimony? Most statutes in the United States of America do not allow for voluntary intoxication to justify any kind of criminal activity. Further, as even remembering a blackout and other related memories is highly subjective, the same cannot be used to testify.
                The fact that such a question should exist is surprising in the first place. A loss of memory in the aftermath of an event in no way implies that the person was not in control of their actions or responsible for them. To see a similar criminal framework, we can refer to the Wilson vs. U.S case that took place in 1968.         When the question of his competence was raised in court, the trial court struggled to hold him accountable due to his permanent retrograde amnesia from a car accident. However, they eventually found him guilty by proving his competence. His capacity to understand and infer details (in the example they used, regarding the case) by relying on alternative sources of information. The U.S court of appeals found that this definition of competence matched the Dusky Standard (the case used to determine competence). Hence, since the expression of blackout presents itself in a similar fashion, it is believed that alcohol blackout cases can be treated according to this standard. The allowance from responsibility and the freedom for persecution is not valid for alcohol induced blackout states.

Bibliography:
(1) Commentary: Alcoholic blackout and allegation of amnesia during criminal acts. Available from: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/8027567_Commentary_Alcoholic_blackout_and_allegation_of_amnesia_during_criminal_acts [accessed May 04 2018].

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Hardin's trauma

“After”, is a 2019 teen romantic drama directed by jenny gage that revolves around the love of  Tessa, an inexperienced teenage girl, with Hardin, a mysterious ‘bad boy’ . Hardin, the main male character, never had a secure relationship with his father. When Hardin was young, his father used to be an alcoholic with a lot of debt. When he was just eight years old, intruders broke into his home looking for his father for money, however, there was only Hardin and his mother. The intruders forced themselves on Hardin’s mother, and Hardin, who was sleeping then, came downstairs to see what was wrong. To Hardin’s shock, his mother was being raped by three men, one by one. Hardin’s mother told him to leave, however, one man forced him to watch everything.  I would assume that Hardin has PTSD as a result of this incident, and in this paper I will try to prove it. Symptoms of PTSD and scenes that prove Hardin had it: The person subsequently re-experiences the event through both intrusive memori

Disorderly Delvian: A Deep Dive into "Anna Delvey" through the Lens of NPD

       A markedly thick accent, a mop of blonde hair, a magical array of unimaginably expensive clothing, and an air of calculated mystery mesh uncomfortably together to invent Anna Delvey, the centre of Netflix’s appropriately named documentary/drama series, “Inventing Anna”. This series tells or rather retells the fascinating story of how one woman deceived the creme de la creme of New York society as well as some prestigious financial institutions under the guise that she was a wealthy heiress from Germany. The series follows a journalist, Vivian Kent, as she tries to uncover the carefully constructed web of lies Anna spun around high society after her arrest, heavily interspersed by flashbacks, present-day court hearings, and interviews with the enigma herself (Shondaland, 2022). Anna as a character, infused with a troubling reality and a dramatised narrative, presents an interesting scope to study the symptomatology of Narcissistic Personality Disorder as presented in her behaviou

The Psychological Depth of Good Will Hunting

Shorya Sehgal Good Will Hunting revolves around the interaction of two rebellious characters, Sean Maguire and Will Hunting, who, to a certain extent, help each other to conform slightly. Will is a brilliant but troubled, young adult. He suffers from post traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), inferiority complex, defence mechanisms and attachment disorder. A mathematical genius, Will had a complete disrespect for authority and for his own considerable talents. As the story progressed, I was able to see Will’s personal growth as he developed an extremely strong relationship with his therapist, Sean. Sean had fought his own battles in life which had made him tough. This significantly helped Will and Sean to connect to each other on a deep, emotional level. What struck me the most in the movie is how coherently Will's journey is tied together. His transition from an inexpressive, troubled young guy to a mature and responsible one is shown very exquisitely. By the end, he was able to be