Skip to main content

Reflection on the views of Thomas Szasz

Anushree Saboo

Exam bonus 

In his book titled, "The Myth of Mental Illness: Foundations of a Theory of Personal Conduct," Thomas Szasz goes too far in claiming that mental illness is a myth. Szasz argues against the illnesses of the mind and says that naming problems which we today call "mental illnesses" is a logical error.
Though Thomas Szasz would love to have a world without psychiatry, it seems horrendous to even think of that as a possibility. Achieving a utopic world without any mental illnesses would be idealistic but mental illnesses do exist and it is wrong not to acknowledge that.  

Szasz accepted that people have problems in their life and coping difficulties but did not want to label these problems as "mental diseases" rather call them "difficulties in living." But his supporters failed to notice that Szasz's definition of disease is very narrow. His definition of disease is obsessively centred around cellular pathology which interprets disease as alterations in the body at a cellular level. In his views against Thomas Szasz, Robert Evans Kendell pointed out that if Szasz's notion of 'disease' was supported then diseases like migraine would fail to qualify into the category. There is no singular perspective on the way diseases are defined in medicine. 

Psychiatrists can help alleviate 'problems in living,' according to Szasz, and this should happen through a contract rather than coercion. He also states that psychiatrists should not believe that they have the utmost authority over such problems and the highest expertise to help people. This is true and can create problems in the society. If psychiatrists are portrayed as having the solution to all 'problems in living,' people will become overly dependent on them to solve their issues. This undermines the ways one can help themselves. 

Szasz highlights individual rights and people's personal responsibility of their life and problems, but there are some cases where people with mental disorders lack the capability of coping with their difficulties and in such cases, psychiatric intervention and psychopathology can assist and bring about positive results. 

Labeling has always been an issue in the field of psychology. Should we let professionals define what we are going through? Arguments made by Thomas Szasz about the medicalisation of 'problems of living' lead us to the issue of over diagnosis in today's society. The number of psychiatric diagnoses is increasing fast and the criterions for existing ones have been lowered, leading to problem in people being labeled with a certain mental health problem. Many writers, critics and psychologists share Szasz's concern in this aspect but calling mental illness a myth is overdoing it. There is a reality attached to psychological dysfunction and many people suffer because of it. Hence, to completely dismiss the idea of the "mind" and its associated problems is unjustified.



References:

https://www.cambridge.org/core/journals/bjpsych-bulletin/article/no-such-thing-as-mental-illness-critical-reflections-on-the-major-ideas-and-legacy-of-thomas-szasz/3F024F2B9FB9766E5A7C489047207EDC/core-reader

https://www.psychologytoday.com/intl/blog/reality-play/201209/revisiting-the-myth-mental-illness-and-thomas-szasz

Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Scarlett O' Hara Diagnosed

By Ragini Chatterjee   (Overall Grade Remedial) A case study on Scarlett O' Hara from ‘Gone with The Wind’   Scarlett O' Hara has to be one of the most vivacious character, on print. With her southern Belle ‘ Fiddle de dees ’, bright green eyes and sharp tongue, she is hard to forget. After having seen the movie multiple times from age 13, I was fascinated by her personality. Her antics, at times cruel, bought the story to life. Her obsession with Ashley, her multiple marriages, her cunning mind and relentless spirt were always entertaining from the perspective of the viewer. However, years later as I look back, I can’t help but recognize patterns of behavior that may resonate with some personality disorder. From the beginning of the movie, Scarlett has to be the centre of attention . At the Wilkes Party, in her attempts to drive Ashley jealous, she flirts with every man in sight- Starting with Charles Hamilton, Frank Kennedy, the Tarleton twins, she promis...
Post a Comment
Read more

PTSD and its portrayal in Peaky Blinders

AARYAN SANWAL The award-winning TV series, Peaky Blinders is set in Birmingham, England at the end of the First World War and gives an account of the Peaky Blinders that is headed by the Shelby family. Thomas Shelby was a tunneller in World War I and for his actions, received two medals of honour after the war.   This blog post shall look at the representation of war trauma, its accuracy in depictions and its effects on the lives of the characters. The two main characters that this blog post will be focusing on are Thomas Shelby and Daniel Owen (a.k.a. Danny Whiz-Bang). The two of them were tunnellers in the War and were going through a routine tunnel expedition when the Germans broke through the end of their tunnel and attacked the men in the tunnel and brutally injured Thomas and Daniel. They were able to kill the enemies and leave the tunnels, alive but severely injured. During various instances throughout the show, Thomas Shelby has recurring nightmares of his time i...
Post a Comment
Read more

Is Patrick Jane a psychopath?

Under the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM), Psychopathy was never recognized, until the revised DSM-5 categorized it under Anti-Social Personality Disorder. “He will choose you, disarm you with his words, and control you with his presence” (Hare)  Psychopaths can replicate the behavior which the person they are interacting with thinks they want from them, without feeling a thing, which contributes greatly to their ability to manipulate. Psychopaths charm and lie their way seamlessly to the top, and while they lack empathy, they are well-liked because they know what to say and when to say it. Psychopaths occupy most of the positions of power in our society and corporations and thus often end up being glorified. This glorification of psychopaths is most evident in the portrayal of psychopathy in TV shows. Some of the most notable characters which the screen has ever seen, like Marlo Stanfield from ‘The Wire’, James Moriarty from ‘Sherlock’, Hanni...
Post a Comment
Read more